Friday, June 26, 2009

The Digital Divide - How will the new online "meritorcracy" of the 21st century impact socioeconomic class mobility in a capitalistic society?

Wow, that is a huge question! And it really leads us to a tangled web of continuous questions (it ironically takes place on a "web" as well).

While I certainly do not know enough about this topic to speak with authority, I do have a couple comments and questions to pose:

1. I love the fact that thanks to Web 2.0 technologies, we are now more than ever, on an equal playing field when it comes to creating and contributing to the global online culture. And this WILL effect offline culture. In many ways it already does.

2. While most of us have access to this technology, regardless of our socioeconomic background, many in rural, urban, and other impoverished areas have not had the support system to understand and use this resource to their ultimate benefit.

3. As a human race we have come so far in the past 100,000 years (a blink of an eye in the history of our planet). For many years, people were concerned with preservation of the species and themselves rather than "contributing to society". Although it's not always considered, many people in the lower strata of the social structure are still in this mode. Who has time (or motivation) to learn to be an online "creator" when they are working in back breaking labor just to pay the bills, heat the house, and put food on the table? Not to mention that they often have to choose which of these three will be their priority for the current paycheck...

4. The above concerns relate to the United States. What about 3rd world countries who don't have our bountiful resources and opportunities?

I guess when it comes down to it, I wonder (not with any distrust or paranoia, just pure wonder!) where the path will lead. Will the online social meritocracy and capitalistic society float through the future in parallel harmony? Will there be a point where fiercely competitive commerce chokes out the unprivileged individual's access to open source opportunities? Will the online meritocracy find hold in the physical world and transform our socioeconomic (as opposed to just social) hierarchy in ways we don't yet envision? Or will we see an evolution of social and economic factors which is driven by a fusion of the needs, desires, and possibilities of our new and ever changing world?

Here is a Blogpost that I found on a similar topic.

2 comments:

Rachel said...

Jim,
These are really great points to raise. There is certainly a strand of "technological utopianism" in a lot of New Media rhetoric that it's important to identify and think more critically about.

The key from the Wired article you found is that power/knowledge/work has become decentralized (which is, actually, much more capitalist an idea than socialist or communist...but then, capitalism in its theoretical form promotes equality too!). There is no "place" that one can be to privilege them above another in a different "place". The only way we can "position" ourselves is with aptitude and...more difficult to instill: motivation.

I'd love it if you kept writing about this. Your points are well put and well taken.

Here's another article that will interest you:

http://news.cnet.com/Technology-and-the-new-class-divide/2010-1028_3-5924758.html

Mr. Dorsey said...

Jim--

I really liked the conversation you brought up in class but I think you did a great job in voicing your concerns. This dialogue had great clarity and concern for the tools we have been entrusted to teach.